Hallmark’s When Calls the Heart Cast’s Dating History: Pics

Hope Valley is full of love triangles and complex love stories, but the cast of When Calls the Heart’s real-life romances aren’t quite as hard to keep track of.

Erin Krakow, Chris McNally and Kevin McGarry are just some of the Hallmark Channel stars who have become family throughout the show’s run, which began in 2014.

During that time, the protagonist Elizabeth Thatcher (Krakow) has found love more than once. Off screen, Krakow has been much quieter about her love life, but in June 2025, she wed WCTH costar Ben Rosenbaum.

McNally has been equally as hush-hush about his relationship with fellow Hallmark star Julie Gonzalo, with whom he shares one child. They announced in December 2025 that they are expecting again.

McGarry, meanwhile, met his now-wife Kayla Wallace on WCTH. The couple went public in fall 2020 before getting hitched in 2022.

Scroll down to see which When Calls the Heart stars are off the market — and who’s still single: